My V-Pick Review
Guitarists are serious about their tones. They will spend large sums of money on rack-mount gear, effect pedals, custom guitars and boutique amps – searching out a tone that may elude them, and when found may soon become uninspiring to the ears. The next step typically is to buy more pedals, or try a different guitar and amplifier – all viable courses of action. It is because of the diverse and complex nature of the guitar’s sound, more so than with drums, bass or other instruments, guitarists rarely are completely satisfied.
Although we can be particular or ‘picky’ when it comes to picks, far less is discussed about this medium than with other guitar gear. And this is ironic since picks are very inexpensive... even the custom-designed versions, relative to what is spent on anything else associated with guitar playing – including guitar magazines! But the important point is this: with the same guitar, same amp, and same pedals, the sound that emanates from within can vary considerably by two things... 1) the player; and 2) the pick.
Give the same gear to Eric Clapton, and he will sound very different from Steve Vai, even if they play the same thing. It’s not only what is being played, but how. Although you cannot step into the body of another player, and may not be able to afford the gear that player uses, picks do offer a tangible solution to altering tone and dynamics. If this were not the case, there would not be so many companies making so many styles, thicknesses and sizes, and from so many materials (including rock, bone, plastic, nylon, metal, et cetera). And many professional guitarists get their picks custom made! Yes, there is an obvious difference in what pick is being used, as well as the comfort factor of the player in having his or her pick ‘just so.’
I have used dozens of different picks over the years, from thin to thick; from serrated to rounded; from plastic and vinyl to nickel-silver tipped. Only recently I was somewhat happy with my choice of pick, a grooved thumb and finger rest to prevent slippage, together with a nickel-silver tip for better control and speed, and improved technique to some degree. It was then that I spotted an advertisement for the award winning V-Picks, claiming to never drop your pick again and to improve technique. It’s not so much that I was in the market for a new pick, but when you have all the gear you need, and then some, you’re always looking for guitar ‘candy’ and the V-Pick seemed an appropriate and inexpensive investment. When visiting the website, I was confused at the sheer number of different styles and gauges; I did not know what to purchase, with picks ranging from .75 mm to a whopping 11.5 mm! I started off with three styles, ranging from somewhat thin (Switchblade) to somewhat thick (Snake); not long after that I acquired even more V-Picks to round out my collection and tone possibilities (all in a designer velvet-lined box, which looks rather spiffy in my recording studio – also check out his other accessories, like wrist-band pick holder and guitar strap pick holder).
Before discussing the tonal quality of the individual V-Picks, here is a little more background on these boutique products that will change your mind about plectrum possibilities. The designer, Vinni Smith, is a skilled musician who spent years looking for suitable picks; he was and is in the trenches when it comes to design and R&D of his acrylic V-Picks. In fact, when I spoke with him on the phone he had to turn down his grinder. That’s right – these are handmade one at a time!
The general design is unique, in that each pick has a diamond-shaped bevel all around the edge; and so, no matter where you grip it, and if it moves between your thumb and finger(s), there is an appropriate edge that will make contact with the strings. With this edge, sweeping is far more effortless and clean sounding, and speed picking nary a concern as it glides over the strings. Guaranteed, you will feel a difference in picking technique and quality as the edge refuses to ‘catch,’ ‘drag’ or produce excess friction. You also get more volume from your instrument without trying. Although a light touch gives a softer sound, when it comes to rock and metal, trying to get as much edge and volume from your bass or guitar, I have yet to find a better pick (without generating excess transient noises). Acoustic guitarists also take note!
As well, having a V-Pick move or rotate does not seem to be an issue; they simply stay in place, although not sticky. This means you do not have to grip has hard as the acrylic material reacts very nicely with the heat of the hand. As a studio musician, I don’t tend to get sweaty and drop picks often, but it does happen – that is until V-Picks. I have yet to drop one.
Regardless of the pick you choose, although I recommend an assortment for different applications, the acrylic material of these picks really bring out the mid-tones. This is vital for the guitarist to understand, since the frequency range of the electric guitar (barring muddiness and hiss) is from around 100Hz to about 8kHz and with the mid-range of 1-6kHz that ‘cuts through the mix.’ And the V-Pick helps you to do just that just as effectively as tweaking your EQ.
In general, regardless of the manufacturer, the thinner the pick the more bite or edge you get from it. The thicker the pick the more warmness and smoothness you will hear. Likewise, the more pointed the tip the more bite and edge, and the rounder the tip, the more warmness and smoothness. This holds true for the various V-Picks available, although the dynamics and tones are far superior and obvious when compared to traditional picks. Having read a few reviews on V-Picks, the biggest (and about only) complaint is the clicking or ‘chirping’ sound heard when playing, since the dynamics are so apparent. I question the reviewer’s experience on a few bases. First, turning up the drive on an amp too much will make any pick ‘chirpy,’ which calls into place effective noise gating. Too much treble in the mix also produces this outcome. Second, moving to a thicker V-Pick gauge reduces any audible ambient sounds if still an issue. Third, I don’t hear any such effect from my playing or in my recordings. From my perspective and my ears, the thinner picks merely give more bite and edge, which characteristic is not for every player, and that may have been the issue.
Speaking of thicker picks, if the reader is not accustomed or familiar with V-Picks s/he may be apprehensive about some of Vinni’s products. When I first took the Snake (4.10mm thick) out of its package (no jokes necessary), my first thought was “why the heck did I buy this?” After a few minutes of play, it was amazing – a warm, yet powerful, and rich tone that allowed me to play as fast as I could or desired to, and to even achieve pinch harmonics. Further note that the thicker V-Picks should not be compared to other heavy gauge picks from various guitar manufacturers. I’m uncertain what it is about the acrylic material, although I believe it has more to do with the overall design and diamond edge, but thick V-Picks feel as graceful and easy to use as any regular pick – not clumsy in the least and not the same as using a heavy gauge plastic pick.
The only other negative comment I have read concerning V-Picks is the cost. I find this perplexing, considering the large sums of money spent on gear, and with V-Picks starting at only $2.99; however, when accustomed to paying $1 or less for a pick, then buying one for the price of a beer seems horrific to some guitarists. But with all things in life, it depends on one’s priorities and values.
But are there any negative points to these picks? If you were to use only one, such as the Shredder, then a person likely would complain that the tone is not right, or that it does not work well when playing the blues or when using an acoustic guitar. But with so many V-Pick styles to choose from, it is difficult to fault any one pick relative to what is designed to do.
(a Billy Gibbonism)
