Dreadman said:
Wings really knows his music electronics. Maybe he could look over the specs for the Guitar Tracks software and let us know how it compares to some common stand alones.
Thanks for that, D-man, but I really know jack about computer-based recording systems or track manipulation other than it's surely more powerful and less limited than using a DAW-based system like those in the Boss BR series. And that you can encounter latency issues, OS conflicts, periodic upgrades of software and/or hardware due to the planned obsolescence of that industry.
If you're doing a 'pro' studio thing, definitely: gotta be computer, and it best be ProTools based studio. But if you're a home recording hobbyist that's a musician first and recordist 2nd, you don't 'need' a computer.
Whatever I know was built from working with tape and analog studio gear, from just a bit later than after Hannibal crossed the Alps with it, and then finally exploring what digital recorders could do about 7 years ago with the Boss unit I mentioned. My thing is a hybrid of 'old-school' techniques and tools augmented by and mixed with a DAW's ease & convenience.
[Edit: I just figured out how, and made a link to my current home studio setup in my sig. If interested, there it is...]
Most important plus for me with digital is you don't get the degradation, noise and bleed like with overlaying and submixing analog tape tracks. I still use analog gear as signal sources, or if it's a digital source, I convert or run it through an analog device to keep things 'warm & fuzzy'. To me, purely digital is too 'glassy' sounding, but that's just my opinion.
Also, I prefer to leave room for human error and spontaneity in the musical performance; there can be a tendency to rely on a computer (or even a DAW) to fix mistakes, correct pitch...extinguish any human touch.
That said, I don't in any way mean to say one can't or shouldn't start with a computer system. Your suggestion of Guitar Tracks as one simple way to go is surely a good one. If it's more convenient to go that route, than by all means, it's the way to go. But....a standalone unit like the 'little' Boss BR600 is independent and more easily portable.
Sun Valley Steve admits to being a neophyte with recording. I think applying the KISS principle may be the simplest way to start. Whether it's computer or DAW.