Mission Accomplished
Short story told long... My son is an aspiring blues harp player living in NYC. We chatted often about the virtues of tube amps in creating that wonderful overdriven sound from the early blues recordings. He bought a Crate V 5 from GC in NYC maybe 2 years ago. It had some difficulty right off the bat. The magnet fell off the speaker!? you can imagine the effect that had on the sound, which was already cheesy because of the flimsy stock speaker.
Anyway, he brought the amp home to Philly, and left it with me while he was touring in a traveling theater production. I replaced the stock speaker with a Jensen C10R. I was concerned about getting a speaker with a larger magnet because of potential size issues. No problem it fit right in an the improvement in sound was apparent and impressive, altho a little harsh an no bottom end. Googling Crate V5 mods, i came upon this site and thread. It was my good fortune to read Deafelectromarks assessment of the design and his comments about the simple mods he did which apparently had a great effect on the sound of this little amp. I corresponded with Mark, and being cautious about doing such a mod myself and fearing electric shock or worse, I sent the whole chassis to Mark. Mark and I dialoged many times about the progress, during which I asked him many inane questions about guitars, amps etc. My naievete was obvious but he answered my questions in thoughtful and informative manner. When I got the amp back, and turned it on, I was a little disturbed; weak sound and not real loud. Shortly thereafter a loud squeal really freaked me out. Bad power tube? I tapped the stock Sovtec EL84 and yes, it did crackle and pop. Out it came and in went a vintage GE EL84 Mark had sent along with the amp. Ahhhh! Much better, tho not a huige amount of overdrive. Corresponding with Mark about my concerns, we deceided to go with a new JJ EL84. I bought two matched from Tubedepot for 17.95 on sale. When they arrived i tore open the box, plugged one in with a new Tungsol 12AX7 and WOW!. Sweet sparkly clean tones and a throaty OD tone I was hoping for. My son came home for TG and we jammed a bit. He was totally enamored with the sound of this amp now. His harp mike will OD the amp when on about 5. With a vocal mike, it creates a Little Walter sound, and a roomy almost reverb effect. My Strat with the amp on 6-7 reminds me of Live at Leeds or some of the brighter ACDC tones. So, thanks Mark for deconstructing this little gem and bringing it back to life.
PS: My son is giving me back my BJ and taking the CrateV5, believe it or not, the Crate sounds better!