Andy
I don't know. I built up a 25 dollar affinity strat into one awesome guitar with 160 dollars worth of SD pups and a pickguard and tone pot. I had some Fender locking tuners laying around.
I can always take these parts and put them on my Squire standard strat, or my Hwy 1 in the bridge or neck, but it sounds great as is.
That affinity is light and has an incredible flammed maple neck, you wouldn't believe the tones. I think it comes down to individual guitars, with price just being a guideline. Electronics are cheap. My affinity has an alder body and an awesome neck. I'm thinking of the GFS trem or a Wilkinson.
First, I'm going to A/B it to my Fender '07 Hwy 1 and see how it stacks up; the affinity has SD "hot rail" in neck, " 'lil 59" in mid, and "JB Jr in bridge", plus the Fender locking tuners. I am assuming the affinity is going to sound better than the Hwy 1, but a test will quickly tell.
If not the pickups will be switched to the Hwy 1 in the neck and mid and so will the tuners. I already put solid stainless steel saddles on the Hwy 1, which I like much better than the bent metal.
Duffy
However, I A/B'd several of my guitars and the stock guitars without variance proved to my ear that the significantly more expensive guitars in the same class, LP, strat, tele, etc., sounded better than their substantially cheaper counterparts.
This does not prove that you can't hot rod a cheaper guitar and make it sound and play superior to a stock Epi LP standard or Fender Hwy 1 Fat strat, but it does have some face value, from my limitted standpoint.
Even my P90 Squire tele Custom II w duncan designed noise cancelling in the middle position position sounded considerably better than my set neck all mahogany including neck SX Gibson LP Special copy with SX P90 pups which were not noise cancelling. Maybe some better P90 pups would sound better. I would try the hot Seymour Duncan ones or some comparable GFS high end ones. But the SX sounds real good as is just not as chimey and nice as the Squire tele Custom II.
My Epi Birseye maple top LP Standard limitted edition sounded, along with its real Seymour Jazz open coil pup in the neck and corresponding SD JB in the bridge, way better than my ESP LTD EC-50, which sounded real good then extremely good after I put the original pups from my Epi LP standard plus top in it, did not sound nearly as good as the Epi Lp STD Birdseye top w SD hot rodded pups in it.
So, the more you can spend on a guitar to begin with, or buying a less expensive guitar like a Classic Vintage Squire or Squire Deluxe, is going to sound way better to begin with and will probably require no or minimal modification.
Plus, with modification, often you run into unforseen things that also need to be modified in order to get your guitar up to what your goal is; like new pickguards, tuners, pots, technical assistance from a pro, etc.
I enjoy hot rodding guitars. It is fun. But there is still something to be said about buying a real quality guitar regardless of it's price, to begin with.
When I compared my G&L semi hollow swamp ash top maple fretboard telecaster to my Squire standard telecaster, there was no comparison actually. Very apparent tele tones to the G&L Tribute semi hollow swamp ash tele, much better sound all the way around, '07 model, amazing tele, sustain city. I want to hot rod my Squire now.
*****Question for the tele experts******:
I have a Fender tele Custom Shop tele bridge pup right now on hand. Does anyone think this would sound good in the Squire Standard tele? Improve the sound? Will it be noise cancelling like the Squire standard is now? Sounds like a very good idea.
I don't want to spend the time to test it without some opinions from some knowledgeable tele people. I don't want to waste my time. But I'm expecting that the stock pickups in the Squire Standard tele are about 20 dollars max and the Fender Custom Shop bridge pup is probably over twice that price, plus it is about 5 years old.
Input appreciated.
Duff
It does not say what Custom shop the pup is but just says Custom shop. Does this make any sense?