Marnold is much more an expert than I. I never brewed from all grain, but rather used extracts. Non hopped. Prehopped extract can be nasty. I prefer whole hops to pellets. I also preferred to use dry extract rather than canned thinking it gave a little bit more flavor, and depending on the recipe, plenty of specialty grains for flavor and/or color. I like to use Wyeast yeast, and on some recipes would throw in a pack of dry champagne yeast to finish off fermentation nicely.
I have used a variety of whole hops including
Cascade (boiling)
Domestich Saaz (boiling)
Hallertau (finish)
English or Kent Goldings (finish)
Tettnanger (finish)
Fuggle (finish)
Seems like Cascade is my go to boiling hop as I look over old notes.
I would love to figure out a recipe to capture the flavors of both Deschutes Greenlakes Organic, and their new Red Chair, and also Stone Ruination IPA.
I have fixings for kind of a scottish ale (like Mack and Jacks kinda) that I may brew up this spring to get into it. Very easy recipe.
In my Christmas beers, I was never afraid to add some honey, a little molasses, ginger, orange rind, a bit of spice (but not too much, too much anise or nutmeg is not pretty), cinnamon, etc. Usually, I had plenty of 6.0LCrystal, maybe some Chocolate or Caramel grains, and some Black Patent to provide some back up and support for the extra spices and such. Never ever do I use sugars for fermentation.