Fozzy said:
It has a 5 way p/up switch. I use the bridge humbucker setting most of the time--it has quite a bit of clout. The middle and neck pickup settings sound OK. I use them for clean sounds. It is the "in between" pickup settings (positions 2 and 4) that I find quite disappointing. They are both weird sounding and insubstantial--lacking in something, not sure what exactly. I never use those settings.
I see another thread on the subject of out phase problems for these settings stemming from wrong wiring. I am just wondering if I might have the same problem. I have the wiring scheme from the Squier site. I will have to open up the back and have a look sometime.
The 2 and 4 positions on a 5-way Strat switch are generally a parallel-wired connection of the two pickups from the switch positions on either side, i.e. position 2 is the bridge & middle in parallel, and 4 is the middle & neck. You referenced these positions "lacking in something", and that is exactly correct--being in a parallel orientation, there will be some signal cancellation between the two pickups, which leads to a characteristic slightly hollow/nasal character with somewhat reduced volume that is commonly referred to as the Strat "quack". However, this is considered to be a
good tone by many Strat players; indeed, it is the
favorite of some! So I suppose that it's just possible that you don't care for the "quack" sound.
However, the other possibility is the one you've mentioned--miswiring, so that the 2 and/or 4 positions have the selected pickups not only in parallel, but also
out of phase. In this case, you get a
very thin, super-trebly tone of significantly reduced volume. I'm quite familar with this sound, because I ran into exactly this situation when I replaced the stock pickups in my Fullerton ST4 HSS guitar a few days ago. It turned out that the humbucker I used was wired with the opposite polarity of the two single coils (they were from different sources), so in switch position 2, the humucker at the bridge was out of phase with the middle single-coil p'up. Nasty sounding! However, position 4 was fine (i.e. normal position 4 "quack"), because the two single coils were from the same set and were properly phased. So I just ended up reversing the hot and ground lead connections for both single coils, and all sounded well again.
For
both position 2 and 4 to be out of phase, then the middle pickup would have to be wired in backwards relative to both the neck and bridge, which would definitely be pretty weird. Not impossible, though, by any means....