Surprise! Advice Needed Thread.

[Katastrophe]

It all depends on what feels good to you in your hands. No one particular guitar really works "best" for one particular type of music. There are, however, types that, over time, have become associated with specific genres, like the Telecaster for country, big hollowbodies for jazz, et cetera.

That said, the Tele would be hard to beat, as it has been played successfully in each genre you mentioned. Twang for days on rockabilly and surf, and it can get really nasty sounding for punky stuff. Lots of metal playing might require a pickup swap to a single coil sized humbucker, but it wouldn't change the appearance that much. It really is a versatile guitar, and is affordable.

Of course, a P90 equipped Les Paul type guitar would get you there quite nicely as well, and can be found at reasonable prices through Epiphone, Rondo music and others.

One thing that you can count on though is that your tastes will change and you'll want another guitar. It's called GAS, and is unavoidable, especially on this forum. I have a Strat that my wife bought for me because of the GAS here, and I love it. Very versaitile as well!

 

[duhvoodooman]

VIking Power, as you can see:

1. You'll get no shortage of gear suggestions/opinions around here, and
2. They will vary widely, with some being almost diametrically opposed to others.

Bottom-line: Sift through it, see what makes sense and seems to fit your particular situation best, and then go out and do some hands-on research. Despite the complaints you'll read about Guitar Center here (much of it well-deserved), there are few better places to go if you want to be able to check out a wide variety of guitars, amps and associated gear. Once you've pinned down what you want, you can then decide on how/where you want to acquire it.

I'd also urge you not to rush the process too much. GAS (gear acquisition syndrome) is a powerful motivator, but hasty buying decisions often result in disappointment and disillusionment after the initial excitement wears off. It's not easy sometimes, but take your time!

One other thing--we strongly encourage newcomers to our little forum to stop over at the The Fret Players forum and introduce themselves.

 

[thearabianmage]

VIking Power, as you can see:

1. You'll get no shortage of gear suggestions/opinions around here, and
2. They will vary widely, with some being almost diametrically opposed to others.

+1 and +1

and again +1 on taking your time and finding 'the right one'!

 

[tot_Ou_tard]

Guitars & amps are a curious thing. Who knows why a person is attracted to one type over another. Do research & narrow down to a list that have good reputations & that somehow speak to you.

Once you make these yours by playing them for enough time, you'll start to understand what makes you tick & then the GAS will really kick in.

Good luck!

 

[sunvalleylaw]

Normally, I would recommend a good strat for a first electric. Just so versatile. But I will throw another one out there because of your list of genres and your screen name: Hagstrom Viking semi-hollow. It can rockabilly, it can punk, and metal. The only thing I wonder about is surf. No whammy bar, and surf is just so strat. For an amph, I suggest you try out the Peavey Vypyr and Vox modelers. I did, and ended up choosing my Peavey Classic 30 ($250-350) tube amph that is very versatile with some pedals, but metal may be a stretch. It does give you the tube goodness though. And one other suggestion, if you wanted to go with a tube amph, you could check out the Line 6 M13 stompbox modeler ($400-500). It will have all the sounds you need plus more and is very intuitive and adjustable and is getting good reports. (See Spudman's review) If I was starting from scratch, I would consider doing that. So, if I was starting over, I might go a good strat, similar to mine used, or a Squire Classic Vibe 60's ($300)(my choice, you might prefer the 50's), or the Squire Deluxe strat which you can find new for $250 or under on the internet, a used Peavey Classic 30, and that Line 6 M13. I would also check out some semi-hollows, especially the Viking. If you were careful, you could do that for right about a grand, and have a great setup!

But I agree with the others that you should go out and play some stuff and see what you like. It will come to you.

Anybody care to recommend a setup for me ? Here are my thoughts/criteria:

• Have a LONG way to go before I ever think about "gigging".
• Want to play surf.
• Want to play punk.
• Want to play metal.
• Want to play rockabilly.
• Don't want an "el-cheap-o" setup. Willing to spend maybe $1000 total (?????? this is flexible).

Thanks in advance!!!!!:rockon:

 

[Viking Power]

Normally, I would recommend a good strat for a first electric. Just so versatile. But I will throw another one out there because of your list of genres and your screen name: Hagstrom Viking semi-hollow. It can rockabilly, it can punk, and metal. The only thing I wonder about is surf. No whammy bar, and surf is just so strat.

Oh man that Hagstrom Viking is a beeeeeaauuutiful piece of work (well at least from the pix on-line anyway!)! Don't know the first thing about semi-hollows and now I'll need to do some research on them.

Surprised to find out that so many pros in the punk genre use these!

Also, I have to admit-I like the name:AOK: !

 

[thearabianmage]

Oh man that Hagstrom Viking is a beeeeeaauuutiful piece of work (well at least from the pix on-line anyway!)! Don't know the first thing about semi-hollows and now I'll need to do some research on them.

Surprised to find out that so many pros in the punk genre use these!

Also, I have to admit-I like the name:AOK: !

Could this be the first signs of GAS?

 

[markb]

My advice on this? Stratocaster with a humbucker in the bridge position, that'll cover all the styles you list. A coil tap on the 'bucker will allow you to get some of those thinner surf sounds too, but I'd go with the middle single coil for most of that stuff. Fender amp! Accept no substitutes, you'll need that gorgeous drippy reverb for both surf and rockabilly. Get your heavier styles from pedals, a Marshall-in-a-box type would be good here, e.g. Boss DS-1, RAT, Marshall GV-2. A VOX modelling amp would cover these styles too. The reverb needs a bit of tweaking to get it to full Fender glory though but it's all there in the controls.

If you do get tempted down the 335-alike route, a Bigsby is not a difficult job to fit especially on a guitar that already has a trapeze tailpiece like the Hagstroms. Here's a video.



And remember, whatever choice you make is the right one 'cause you made it

 

[sunvalleylaw]

Markb, he could get a Fender Bassman, (Brian Setzer, also leading me to semi-hollows) but that would take him over his budget for sure.

Jamie James here, http://www.amazon.com/Kingbees-Vols-1-2/dp/B000009NXF is a good rockabilly strat player though.

 

[Viking Power]

If you do get tempted down the 335-alike route, a Bigsby is not a difficult job to fit especially on a guitar that already has a trapeze tailpiece like the Hagstroms. Here's a video.



And remember, whatever choice you make is the right one 'cause you made it

Thanks for the video. That Bigsby setup looks really cool! Very interesting!

 

[markb]

Markb, he could get a Fender Bassman, (Brian Setzer, also leading me to semi-hollows) but that would take him over his budget for sure.

Jamie James here, http://www.amazon.com/Kingbees-Vols-1-2/dp/B000009NXF is a good rockabilly strat player though.

There's no reverb in a Bassman. Adding the correct outboard reverb unit would go way over budget. Blackface amps are the sound of surf and do the rockabilly thing nicely too. I'd suggest a used Deluxe Reverb reissue for ~$500. You'll never need to buy another amp.

 

[Viking Power]

Ugghh!!!

Still having trouble deciding what to get for an electric guit/amp setup that is going to meet my needs......

Might be able to get a used American Strat for $600-700, but the guy wants all his gear to go as a package deal. Therefore I'd be forced into buying his Crate amp and Blackbox Reloaded as well. Fooled around with his strat unplugged a bit the other day and I was digging it.

My guitar teacher is trying to recommend I get an Epi LP Plain Top. He just got one and really likes it. Can I play surf and rockabilly on it though? :thwap:

Pardon the ramble. Just typing out thoughts........

Chime in if you like.....

Thanks.....

 

[Tarin]

My two cents would be:
Guitar... i don't have much experience for me to suggest one, i love my Parker but a good guess would be a HSS Strat (so many musicians can't be wrong).

For a Versatile amp, i'm sure the Fender Super Champ XD (SCXD) offers the best of both worlds (effects, SS, Tube)

 

[Tarin]

I just remembered... before i bought my Parker, i had my eyes on a Gretsch Electromatic Pro Jet (goldtop, nice).
From what i read, this guitars have nice twang but can also give great RnR tone.
I confirmed this watching a few videos at the U'tube site.

You can find them with or without a Bigsby whammy bar.

 

[markb]

My guitar teacher is trying to recommend I get an Epi LP Plain Top. He just got one and really likes it. Can I play surf and rockabilly on it though? :thwap:

Don't know about surf on a Lester but rockabilly? Well, if it's good enough for Carl.

 

[Viking Power]

Don't know about surf on a Lester but rockabilly? Well, if it's good enough for Carl.

AKKKK!!!!! I'm such an idiot! I thought Elvis did Blue Suede Shoes! :thwap:


*Now reading Carl Perkins wiki*

 

[markb]

AKKKK!!!!! I'm such an idiot! I thought Elvis did Blue Suede Shoes! :thwap:

Elvis covered Blue Suede Shoes (written by Carl Perkins) while Perkins was recovering from a car crash that killed his brothers (in the picture). Thus he never got to capitalise on the song's popularity and felt he never achieved the fame he deserved. Cue battle with drink, etc, etc. See also Charlie Feathers