My hunch is that it's the power tubes that give that little rattle. If you're going to stay with tube amps you better learn to live with it. You are the only one that will notice it unless it's really pronounced. Playing out or in a band situation it would be hard to detect except for a very quiet passage. A new pair of 6L6's may well be the same. It's pretty common with 6V6, 6L6, and rectifier tubes, and it happens with different brands of tubes too. I had a 5E3 with a new Sovtek 5Y3GT that rattled so badly that playing through a different amp that was 10 feet away rattled it.
Tapping on a 12AX7 can give you a sound. That's pretty normal too. A bad pre amp tube usually shows itself as a whine or feedback type of sound, or maybe the reverb stops working, things like that. That annoying little rattle is not likely to be caused by one.