Ch0jin said:
Wingsdad I don't know if I agree with you about resale.
... If we all had '59 Les Paul's at home then they would not be worth far in excess of their MSRP like they are now for example.
You're absolutely correct about rare or vintage guitars, amps & gear, but perhaps I should have qualified my statement about resale values as NOT being in reference to such instruments as a '59 LP. It is indeed a matter of supply & demand of a particular piece.
I was referring to the less remarkable, common pieces, which other than some Fender Limited Edition or Custom Shop models, most MIUSA or MIM Fender & Squier product of the last 10-15 years is just that, and rarely, if ever, will be resold for more than its original MSRP as compared to the current MSRP of the same model ... if it's still produced, the resale value of a common instrument will be generally in the range of what you might be able to buy it for new, today, which is typically a % of the current MSRP, then adjusted slightly up or down dependent on supply & demand in the market it's sold in.
As a starting point, not as gospel, dealers refer to the Blue Books of Electric Guitars and of Acoustic Guitars which show when a model was first & last produced, the last original MSRP and then a
range of current values dependent on condition. In the end, even these guides advise that current value will vary from market to market. Consequently they DO check e-bay to get some idea of resale market value, but that, too, is not gospel.
No price guide or e-bay or Christies auction gives any indication of a potential seller's sentiment or emotion entering into the equation.
In the end, a piece is only worth what someone (market or individual) is willing pay for it. One should never underestimate a buyer's emotion. "One man's garbage is another man's gold".