ww - From the perspective of a moderator, I am going to address your post point-by-point, because I think you've raised a lot of good discussion, and most importantly on a few topics that I don't think anyone has really addressed. Or, at least in the terms of how each member's participation, and collective understanding of the function of the forum affects the "big picture".
There are also many ways in which you can share in camaraderie - the personal message feature, e-mails through, or outside of the forum, chat rooms, blogs, posting sites, etc.
Being cognizant of proper forum protocol should not be looked at as a hindrance, nor should it deter your participation. If this forum is to grow, and move forward, we all need to be aware of our roles and responsibilities as members. And the sooner we can come to terms with it, the better our forum will become. Conversely, if our posts become strewn with non-topical content and chat-room discussion, it will stagnate content-wise, and soon, you too will be looking elsewhere for guitar-related information (if you aren't already!)
Anyways, that's my two cents.
Define "pro". If you mean play in a band, or record professionally, I am neither. I'm an "advanced hobbyist", if that makes any sense at all. And one who has a severe jones for buying gear.i don't think there are very many pros on here.
Have you tried? You just wrote two paragraphs here about why you like this forum. In other words, you put some thought into a response, developed it into written form, and presented it. You've just proven to me that you have all of the tools you need to do it.I could not write an indepth article on anything guitar relate
Me neither. Yet amazingly, I can come up with pseudo-technical content at the drop of a hat . . . ??!! You do not need to have this knowledge to enjoy guitar, and I think it would be safe to assume that the large majority of folks who participate here at FN don't either.I don't know the difference between capacitor types, wave frequencies or whatnot...
I have knock-offs, too, and I write about them all the time. How about what attracted you to purchase those guitars? Did you compare them to the "Real McCoys" before purchasing them? How about the components - are they similar to the higher-priced USA-made models? Feel? Tone? Possible upgrades? Maple vs. rosewood? Single-coil vs. humbucker at the neck? Those all came off the top of my head as fast as I could type them.I have a tele and a strat knockoff but i wouldn't know where to start to come up with a truly informational post in that area of the forum
Why depend on others to contribute to YOUR forum?As the forum grows i'm sure there will be more "traffic". Heck some forums i'm on have hundreds of posts per hour buth they allso have 5-10,000 members instead of a little over 100.
Indeed, I do too. But at some point you need to consider the direction of the forum, and it's collective capacity in presenting and disseminating viable information about its intended subject(s). This is a guitar / bass forum, and thus, we should all be respectful to its basic purpose, that being sharing and discussing things about guitars, bass, and related equipment, along with associated activities, and general musical content. If you want to build traffic to the forum, you first must have something to present, or something of interest to offer. Potential participants / members who come here, and see threads going off-topic, or non-guitar related discussion may look at that detrimentally, and seek to participate / contribute elsewhere.I enjoy the comraderie here including all the non guitar related noise....food, beer whatever. It's like going on a man's night out without leaving the house.
There are also many ways in which you can share in camaraderie - the personal message feature, e-mails through, or outside of the forum, chat rooms, blogs, posting sites, etc.
Being cognizant of proper forum protocol should not be looked at as a hindrance, nor should it deter your participation. If this forum is to grow, and move forward, we all need to be aware of our roles and responsibilities as members. And the sooner we can come to terms with it, the better our forum will become. Conversely, if our posts become strewn with non-topical content and chat-room discussion, it will stagnate content-wise, and soon, you too will be looking elsewhere for guitar-related information (if you aren't already!)
Anyways, that's my two cents.
Last edited: