• You're one step from joining Guitar Discussion Forum - The Fret.
    Create a free account to post, follow threads, and never miss an update.  Sign up free →

Fret Board and Necks

Guitar Discussion Forum - The Fret

Help Support TheFret.net:

just strum

just strum

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
7,753
Reaction score
0
City & State/Province
Northern Ohio - Near Cleveland - Home of the Rock
I have a curiosity question for all you Strat and Strat clone owners out there.

1) What do you prefer - maple or rosewood fret board?

2) What neck (C, V, U...) have you found most comfortable? Why? Are your hands/fingers big or small?

Slowly working my way towards the MIM. I know what model and color, but I would like to hear some preferences on the features noted above.

I'm going to visit a music store to check out different features before I make my decision.
 
I really love a maple neck and fingerboard. For some reason my eye sees positions easier and I like the feel. Sadly once the board starts to wear there isn't much maintenance that can be done to it like you can do to a rosewood board.

For best neck shape it would have to be a V type. Specifically the neck on the Musicman Luke guitars. It is amazingly comfortable and very hard to put down after you pick it up. Incredibly comfortable. Too bad they don't make a maple fretboard version of it.
 
I don't have very big hands, either. In fact, I can barely make the stretch from the 1st to the 5th fret on Strats. I do find Strat C shaped necks comfortable, though it took me a bit to get used to the Standard radius (9.5") as opposed to the Les Paul radius (12") that I'm used to. I'm also a die hard fan of rosewood. No maple fretboards for me. :)
 
Soft V maple, tho I don't mind rosewood, I just think the tinted maple looks cool. I can bend easier on a 12" radius board, but I don't notice a big difference otherwise after playing a few minutes on either.
So many choices, so little time.....money......sigh.:pancake:
 
Hey there Strummy.

I like maple, mostly for appearance reasons but also because they're easier to finish. No masking the fretboard. My hands are about average size and I like thinner necks. Warmoth's "standard thin" (which I think is thinner than any Fenders) is perfect for me, very much like Washburn's acoustic necks (not the bats on the jumbos though).

MIM, huh? May I suggest building from scratch? Between ebay and www.warmoth.com you can put together a killer Strat for as little as $400-$500. My butterscotch baby only cost $700 in parts, all new and very good quality (except the body which is a used USA Fender in like new condition).

If you like the idea I'd be more than happy to help you pick out what you need and guide you through assembly. I'd even build it for you (no charge) if you like.
 
Great post just strum. I was just going to post a question on prefs for shapes. I am looking for a new neck for a project and do not have enough experience playing different shape necks so this post will be great. Thanks:AOK:

I kind of like the '51 neck. It s kind of thick though at the nut.

I also like a 9.5 radius.

My jazzmaster has a flatter compound radius but it makes fretting chords more difficult. The chords in the song Long Train Running are harder to fret on the flatter board. That neck is a standard thin but a compound radius of, 12 to 16. Playing leads is nice though. That also has a PauFerro board which I like a lot.

M29
 
I own two strat types, my MIM 60th, and my Fully. I like the Maple modern C shape on my 60th the best. I like the 9.5 radius on the fret board better than the flatter one on the fully, and just like the feel.
 
just strum said:
I have a curiosity question for all you Strat and Strat clone owners out there.

1) What do you prefer - maple or rosewood fret board?

2) What neck (C, V, U...) have you found most comfortable? Why? Are your hands/fingers big or small?

Slowly working my way towards the MIM. I know what model and color, but I would like to hear some preferences on the features noted above.

I'm going to visit a music store to check out different features before I make my decision.
Click to expand...

1. Maple, though I'm ready for a guitar with rosewood or ebony fret board.

2. C and soft V, 9.5 radius feel very natural to my average size hands.

Can we hear more about the model and color?
 
Well, that depends...

I love the maple neck and fretboard on my Tele. A twangin' Tele needs a maple neck for whatever reason - even if it's just to look cool! But I've seen some sweet Teles with rosewood boards too, hmmm...

I'm GASin' for a Strat with r/w, mostly an aesthetic thing for me.

As far as neck shapes, I find Fender types generally more comfy - mine is a "C", and I like the 9.5" radius.

But every once in awhile, my HB-30 calls to me and her 43mm wide, 12.5" radius neck tucks into my hand ever so sweetly, ahhhh...

I just can't make up my mind. Gonna need one of each I guess :AOK:
 
After years of playing on rosewood fretboards, I got a Strat with maple. It seems to me, and this just may be my ears being goofy, that the maple adds a little snap to the tone.

I am probably one of a very few people that don't like the V neck shape. I played a JV Strat once, and while I loved the tone, the neck just felt awkward to me. I like the C neck shape on the Fender Standards. They are more comfortable to me. I don't have large hands, but I do have semi-long, skinny fingers.

I loved the neck on a '72 Tele Deluxe (or was it Custom? It was the two humbucker version) that I played on a while ago. Perfect fit for my hands, and it felt like a D shape (since it was a 70's model, it probably what Fender calls a U shaped neck). Anyway, it felt good, and I had a blast playing the guitar.

The 9.5" radius is fine. I've never had any problems with chording or bending, and it's a good compromise.
 
I have always preferred maple necks. I love the look and the tone of maple way more than rosewood. In a way it is brighter and I have the impression that one can control the tones and sounds better on a maple fretboard.

Regarding the shape I love v-shaped necks. Got a v-shaped neck on my Jimmie Vaughan Strat and I have never ever felt more comfortable than with the "V". The reason is that I have not the bigest palm, although my fingers are in comparison pretty long, so for my palm the v is just perfect.

Great thread!
:bravo:
 
I prefer maple, but that's an aesthetic thing. I'd probably prefer ebony to rosewood for the same reason. As far as neck shape goes: flat and thin all the way, baby! My Fender has about the perfect neck for me. Very thin and 15.75" radius. My Floyd is a good middle-ground between my Fender and a typical Fender C-shape. It's got a 12" radius. My '51's neck feels like a baseball bat compared to my Fender.
 
Shape & radius is a 'pesonal feel' thing, but as for the board: Glossed maple. Lacquer. Board & neck.

It's Leo's original 50's design, as he designed the Tele & Strat for Country-Western bar players, with their input & feedback. And part of that is maple's 'snappiness' or briteness vs. rosewood. Less sustain, to a degree, but that's the point. It helps the Strat 'Quack' in the 2 & 4 PUP positions. (that and the middle PUP a shade lower than than either or both the other 2.

a) bends are easier because it's slick
b) doesn't retain grunge
c) low maintenance
d) less wear over time

I've got a 27-year old glossed maple neck on my 81 STRAT. Years of Bar-Wars resulted in a couple of finger board chips and neck dings. They were easy to repair with epoxy fill/stain, and lacquer touch-up.

Heavily-layed areas will wear down the lacquer, but again, it's a simple thing to touch up.

IMO, at least on a Strat or Tele, unfinished/satin necks & boards are a skimpy, cost-saving measure that take less skill to build.
 
wingsdad said:
IMO, at least on a Strat or Tele, unfinished/satin necks & boards are a skimpy, cost-saving measure that take less skill to build.
Click to expand...
I don't think I could disagree with you more on this. I see what you're saying about the durability of a gloss finish, but from a feel perspective, I hate it. During these winter months, it's not a problem. As soon as humidity becomes a factor (and it is in all of the non-cold months here) gloss finishes become far too sticky for my tastes. I would imagine that a good satin finish should be every bit as durable as a gloss one.

That's another reason why I got rid of my Model 7. It had a heavy gloss finish on it that I really didn't like. Having said that, there are plenty of people who value those necks very highly, so different strokes for different folks, I suppose.
 
I really had to think about this one, because I like a couple of different ones.

The neck profile I find most comfortable is a soft V. But, I like the modern C as well, and even a slightly thicker C shape too.

I have an Alvarez acoustic with a very comfortable neck. I've had the guitar for probably 30 years or more, and didn't realize until I had it for at least 10 of those years, that it has a soft V neck profile. I knew that it felt comfortable, I just didn't realize what it actually was.

As to all maple or maple/rosewood (or other fretboards), I say I probably like the rosewood better, only because I've had so many more of them than maple/maple. But...for a slightly brighter tone, and that vintage amber look, I really like maple/maple. I will say that after years of playing the rosewood boards, the maple boards took some getting used to. I think it was as much a visual thing as feel though...or at least I'd like to believe that.

I have, or have had, neck radii in 7-1/4", 9-1/2", 10", 12", 13-3/4" , 10"-16", and 10"-17". After all of that, I find that I prefer a plain, straight 10" radius (or 9-1/2" which is practically the same). It does everything comfortably for me, from chording to bending.

All I can say in conclusion is, I'm glad I'm not limited to only one...:)
 
Dreadman said:
MIM, huh? May I suggest building from scratch? Between ebay and www.warmoth.com you can put together a killer Strat for as little as $400-$500. My butterscotch baby only cost $700 in parts, all new and very good quality (except the body which is a used USA Fender in like new condition).

If you like the idea I'd be more than happy to help you pick out what you need and guide you through assembly. I'd even build it for you (no charge) if you like.
Click to expand...


Sounds good, but this might help explain why not at this time.

http://www.thefret.net/showthread.php?t=5744
 
My Strat and my Tele both have maple boards. I would agree that they seem to have a little extra snap to them. Maple boards also look really cool when the finish wears through and the wood starts to discolor. It helps me justify to my girlfriend that I do actually play all of my guitars.
 
Rosewood. I don't know why.. it's a thing within me since I started playing.. it just looks right and sounds right to me. Just more "charming" if you can say that, the same way I prefer the brunettes. Absolutely nothing against maple.

now talking about radius.. medium to fat C's (you can call it "D shape") and rounder, fatter Vs (unlike the Eric Clapton and Jimmie Vaughan strats). 7,25 on the fretboard.. I'm just so used to it that anything else feels wrong on a Fender. I feel a huge difference when playing different radius of fretboard. The vintage one feels more comfy.

and trust me.. I have hands of a girl, and hate thin necks.. like the MIM standards.
 
All my strats have been c shaped necks with rosewood boards except one. I didn't like that one very much and sold it on pretty quickly.
 
Well, I visited two music shops today and:

1) It's definitely going to be a maple fingerboard. The feel of that board is incredible.

2) Neither store had a V neck, but I do like the modern C. So if I don't come across a V to try out, I have no concern about the modern C.

3) This is sort of funny and Tot you should get a kick out of this - I've thrown the butt-ugly guitar into the mix. I played this in Candy Apple Red and loved it.

http://www.fender.com/products//search.php?partno=0135300367

4) One of my many Strats being considered is this:

http://www.fender.com/products//search.php?partno=0139502355

Unfortunately it doesn't come in Arctic White or Honey Blonde, so if I go with this I will have to settle on another color.

My little window shopping has stirred up some real serious GAS - something I swore I wouldn't entertain this year. (how many more days until 1/1/09?)
 

Similar threads

duhvoodooman
Been buying inexpensive guitars for the past couple of years...
Replies
7
Views
1K
Age
Age
marnold
I'm very confused (G&L USA Legacy content)
Replies
0
Views
178
marnold
marnold
duhvoodooman
Couple of "Partscasters"...
Replies
3
Views
778
Jipes
Jipes
R
My Guitar Herd
Replies
17
Views
1K
Alan
A
marnold
Playing with Strats
Replies
20
Views
2K
duhvoodooman
duhvoodooman

Latest posts

Back
Top