NFL 2012 [American Football Content]

[marnold]

Can't fall behind by 22 and expect the refs to bail you out. Without the power outage the Niners lose by four TDs minimum.

My big thought is that somewhere Browns fans are collectively barfing seeing their former franchise win their second Super Bowl without them appearing in one, much less winning one. Someday my Lions might make it and maybe even win. While I'm dreaming, I'd like a pony.

 

[sunvalleylaw]

It could have been a non-call but I don't think enough to taint the game. If I were a ravens fan I would have been pissed about the lights too.

Overall an entertaining game. I was underwhelmed by the ads this year. We will not speak of Beyouncey.

 

[Tig]

It could have been a non-call but I don't think enough to taint the game.

Overall an entertaining game..

The missed holding call in the end zone on Smith likely cost the game for SF. Two ref's were there and missed it.

Found an animated gif

 

[NWBasser]

The missed holding call in the end zone on Smith likely cost the game for SF. Two ref's were there and missed it.

Yikes, I missed a lot of what happened early in the play. Pretty bad.

 

[sunvalleylaw]

Looking forward to next year. Hoping the Seahawks come back strong to challenge the 49'ers, who have a good number of draft picks I understand. Here is some analysis of the Seahawks needs for consideration by any inclined to read it:

http://blog.thenewstribune.com/seahawks/2013/02/04/the-5-spot-seahawks-in-focus/#more-16885

 

[Tig]

Yep, the Seahawks should do even better next year.

I hope the Texans are still on an upward swing. They have some solid talent that hasn't been utilized by Kubiak.

 

[R_of_G]

The missed holding call in the end zone on Smith likely cost the game for SF. Two ref's were there and missed it.

Found an animated gif

It's my understanding, from listening to the expert Phil Simms, that the rules are different in the last minute of play of a game and even more different in the last minute of play in a really important game.

I have always hated that nonsense. The rules are the rules no matter how much time is left on the clock or what the potential outcome of correctly enforcing the rules on the game.

I'm all for officials "swallowing the whistle" and "just letting guys play" as long as they do it consistently. Either call the game loose or call the game tight, but do it the same from start to finish. That was defensive pass interference at any other time in the game.

Luckily for me, I didn't particularly care for either team so the outcome was meaningless.

Now I'm looking forward to the Bucs' draft and off-season moves and to our coming NFL 2013 thread.

ps. I read/heard a lot of other so-called "experts" saying that regardless of the holding, it was on Crabtree as a professional wide receiver in a big game to "just make the play." I can not recall hearing a bigger line of garbage without double-checking the Jon Gruden archives. Do not blame a clearly fouled WR for not defying the laws of physics.

 

[NWBasser]

ps. I read/heard a lot of other so-called "experts" saying that regardless of the holding, it was on Crabtree as a professional wide receiver in a big game to "just make the play." I can not recall hearing a bigger line of garbage without double-checking the Jon Gruden archives. Do not blame a clearly fouled WR for not defying the laws of physics.

I agree, that sounds like a load of bunk. Correct me if I'm wrong here, but it looked to me that the ball came down so far out of bounds that a catch in-bounds would have been extremely difficult, if not impossible. Assuming that Crabtree wasn't held that is.

 

[NWBasser]

Looking forward to next year. Hoping the Seahawks come back strong to challenge the 49'ers, who have a good number of draft picks I understand. Here is some analysis of the Seahawks needs for consideration by any inclined to read it:

http://blog.thenewstribune.com/seahawks/2013/02/04/the-5-spot-seahawks-in-focus/#more-16885

That's a great analysis. Thanks for the article Steve.

I'm really looking forward to Wilson's second year.

 

[R_of_G]

I agree, that sounds like a load of bunk. Correct me if I'm wrong here, but it looked to me that the ball came down so far out of bounds that a catch in-bounds would have been extremely difficult, if not impossible. Assuming that Crabtree wasn't held that is.

Agree. He'd have had to have made a catch similar to the one Santonio Holmes made a few years ago for the Steelers. That's difficult enough without a defender all over you.

Incidentally, many people have said that because the ball was "uncatchable" that it justifies the no call. I don't entirely agree. I believe the official closest to the play (the one right there in the freeze frame in Tig's post) should have thrown a flag as soon as the DB molested the WR.

If the other officials then converse and decide that yes, there was holding, but they're waving it off because the ball was not catchable, that would be a correct no-call. This is why I think the NFL's disciplining/grading of officials should be available to the public.